What Brought Us to This Roof?

This project started as a leak complaint but turned into a full structural conversation once we got on the roof. The property is a multi-unit residential building in the San Fernando Valley, and the owner had been chasing water intrusion for some time. From the ground the roof looked tired but passable. From the ridge it told a different story: granule loss across most of the field, ridge caps separating, and vent jack bases sitting in puddles of cracked caulk.

The goal coming in was straightforward: pull everything off, assess what was underneath, fix what needed fixing in the structure, and put a new roof on that would last.

Severely rotted rafter tail and eave sheathing on a multi-unit residential building in the San Fernando Valley
Cross-section of two aged asphalt shingle layers with brittle underlayment and moss growth between them during tear-off
Close-up of old ceramic pipe caps with failed spray-foam bases on a worn asphalt shingle roof before reset
Wide view of finished shingle field with properly seated vent jacks and clean ridge after full reroof completion

Project Gallery

What we found at the eaves confirmed the owner’s worst suspicion. The photo above shows the underside of one eave corner where long-term moisture intrusion had completely destroyed the rafter tail and the sheathing around it. The wood had broken down to a crumbling, fibrous mass, consistent with years of water wicking back under a failed drip edge. This kind of rot doesn’t happen overnight. In the San Fernando Valley, where the National Weather Service Studio City office records the bulk of annual rainfall between November and March, an undetected flashing failure at the eave line can drive this level of structural damage over just three to five wet seasons.

What Did We Find When We Tore Off the Old Shingles?

The tear-off revealed multiple layers of aged asphalt shingles with underlayment that had completely lost its waterproofing function. California’s roofing code limits re-roofing to two layers of asphalt shingles before a full tear-off is required, and this roof had reached that limit. The California Building Standards Code language exists precisely because layered-over roofs trap heat and moisture in ways that accelerate deck deterioration from below.

The cross-section photo shows what we lifted when we peeled back the outermost shingle layer: a sandwich of two asphalt shingle generations separated by an underlayment layer that had turned brittle and cracked. Moss was visible growing between the layers, which tells you moisture had been sitting there long enough to support biological growth. Once you see that, you know the deck below needs a full inspection before anything goes back on. Across this building, we identified and replaced damaged sheathing sections in 4 separate eave zones before any new material went down.

Resetting the Vent Jacks and Pipe Flashings

Every vent jack and pipe flashing on the roof was reset as part of this scope, none of the old penetration seals were left in place. The photos show the style of clay or ceramic pipe caps common on older San Fernando Valley multi-unit buildings, some dating to construction in the 1950s and 1960s. These decorative caps sit over galvanized metal flanges, and the flanges had been sealed previously with spray foam and caulk rather than properly integrated into the shingle courses.

Spray-foam seals around roof penetrations have a practical lifespan of roughly 5 to 7 years before UV exposure causes cracking and separation. On this roof, the foam bases visible in the photo had already started pulling away from the pipe shafts, leaving gaps wide enough to channel rain directly to the deck. We stripped the old sealant, reset each flashing with proper lead or rubber boot collars integrated into the shingle laps, and finished with an appropriate sealant bead only at the final collar edge, not as a structural seal.

Our crews reset 11 individual pipe penetrations and vent jacks across this roof during the same continuous work sequence as the shingle installation, so every penetration was addressed while the surrounding field was open and accessible.

The Finished Roof

The completed shingle field is a full architectural-laminate reroof with proper underlayment, reset penetrations, and rebuilt eave framing at all 4 damaged zones. As of 2025, California’s Title 24 building energy standards require roofing products on low-slope and steep-slope applications in certain climate zones to meet cool-roof reflectance thresholds; the selected shingle product meets the applicable reflectance requirements for this building’s climate zone in the San Fernando Valley.

The wide-angle photo shows the finished slope with the vent jacks properly seated in the new shingle field. The ridge is clean, the field is flat, and every penetration has a visible collar sitting flush against the surrounding courses. Compared to what we lifted off, the difference in surface integrity is immediate. The eave zones where we rebuilt the framing are solid again, and the drip edge is properly lapped over the gutter to break the capillary path that caused the original rot.

This is the kind of project where doing the structural repair at the same time as the reroof is the only approach that makes sense. Putting new shingles over rotted eave framing would have bought a year or two at best before the same water problem reappeared from below.

Get a Straight Assessment Before You Commit to a Reroof

If your building is showing signs of shingle wear, granule loss in the gutters, or interior staining near exterior walls, schedule a roof inspection with Roof Replacement Inc. We will tell you what we find, show you photos from the deck, and give you a written scope before any work begins. Call us or submit an inquiry online to get the conversation started.

Project Details

ScopeFull shingle reroof including tear-off of multiple existing layers, rebuilding of rotted eave and fascia framing, and reset of all vent jacks and pipe flashings across a multi-unit residential building.
ServiceShingle Roof Replacement
Property TypeMulti-unit residential building
LocationStudio City
Materials UsedArchitectural asphalt shingles, asphalt felt underlayment, pipe boot flashings, vent jacks, fascia lumber

Our Service Area: Studio City

Frequently Asked Questions

The most common visible signs are soft or spongy wood at the fascia board, paint peeling on the underside of the eave overhang, and staining or sagging at the soffit. On this project the rot was severe enough that the rafter tails had broken down to a fibrous mass, yet the surface shingles showed only typical age wear. An on-roof inspection is the only reliable way to assess eave framing condition before it fails completely.
Yes. The California Building Standards Code limits asphalt shingle re-roofing to a maximum of two layers; once that limit is reached, a full tear-off to the deck is required before any new roofing material is installed. On this project the existing roof had already reached that limit, which made a complete tear-off mandatory and also allowed us to inspect and repair the deck and eave framing before the new shingles went down.
Spray foam used as a penetration seal around roof pipes typically lasts 5 to 7 years before UV exposure causes cracking and separation. It is not a code-compliant substitute for a properly installed lead or rubber boot flashing integrated into the shingle courses. On this project, the foam bases on all 11 penetrations had already started pulling away from the pipe shafts, which was contributing directly to deck moisture intrusion.
Resetting means the existing pipe or vent cap is removed, the surrounding shingles are pulled back, a new flashing collar is installed and woven into the new shingle courses, and the cap is reinstalled correctly. Replacing goes further when the existing cap or flange is damaged or the wrong size. On this building the ceramic pipe caps were structurally intact, so all 11 were reset rather than replaced, which preserved the original aesthetic while bringing the flashing details up to current practice.
In certain California climate zones, asphalt shingles on both low-slope and steep-slope roofs must meet minimum solar reflectance values under California’s Title 24 building energy standards. The requirement applies based on the building’s climate zone classification and roof slope. On this San Fernando Valley project, the selected architectural shingle product was confirmed to meet the applicable reflectance thresholds for the building’s climate zone.
Moss grows between shingle layers when moisture becomes trapped in the underlayment and cannot dry out. On this tear-off we found moss colonies growing in the space between two existing shingle generations, which confirmed that the underlayment had been failing long enough to support biological growth, typically a period of several wet seasons. Beyond the cosmetic issue, the moisture retention accelerates sheathing decay and significantly shortens whatever useful life remained in the top shingle layer.

Project Details

DATE

October 30, 2026

CLIENT
Work Done
CITY

What Our Clients Say

Google Reviews for Roof Replacement Inc

What Our Clients Say

Posted on Google Google
Crista Klayman profile picture
Crista Klayman
11 November 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
WONDERFUL IN EVERY WAY!!!! Pure perfection from start to finish xoxoxoxo

Owner's reply
It means the world to us to read this, Crista!! Enjoy your beautiful new roof. Please reach out if you ever need maintenance or an inspection in the future. We are always here to help!
Posted on Google Google
Rhonda Britten profile picture
Rhonda Britten
10 November 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Excellent service. Monnix was patient and answered all my questions. And thanks to chatgpt, I had a lot of them. I highly recommend Monnix and Roof Replacement.

Owner's reply
Coming prepared with in-depth research makes for an incredible partnership, and we will certainly pass along your high praise to Monnix! Delivering thorough guidance, reliable craftsmanship, and complete peace of mind is what our Los Angeles roofing team strives for on every single home. We appreciate your support and look forward to keeping your home protected for decades to come.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Patrick D. profile picture
Patrick D.
9 November 2026
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Adolfo and his team did a fantastic job replacing my entire roof. I was on a tight time schedule to complete my roof before a major rain storm, and Adolfo's team got the job done beautifully. I'm grateful my real estate agent put me in touch with this team.
Posted on Google Google
Heather Cook profile picture
Heather Cook
2 November 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Amazing from start to finish. They give you a clear quote at the beginning. Once the job started there was clear communication on what was going on in the project. Adolfo really took time to talk and tell us about our roof. Monnix was also great in facilitating everything. The final product looks great and so far is working great too! I feel like they also have reasonable prices. I had quotes that were lower and quotes that were double. But I think they really wanted to solve our problem so I went with them.

Owner's reply
Hi Heather, we deeply appreciate your trust in Roof Replacement Inc. to protect your home. Adolfo, Monnix, and our entire Los Angeles roofing team always strive to provide transparent guidance and a stress-free experience so you can feel confident in your investment. Enjoy the peace of mind under your new roof, and please reach out if you ever need future maintenance!
Posted on Google Google
Elise Pearlstein profile picture
Elise Pearlstein
29 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Adolfo and his team are total pros. He is very knowledgable and helps with problem-solving. We had a few lingering issues to complete the job and he personally visited the site and made sure that everything was done correctly and that we were happy. The company is well-staffed with good equipment so that helps with their efficiency.

Owner's reply
Working on your property was an absolute pleasure, Elise! We take great pride in finding the right solutions for every unique project, and ensuring your home has decades of reliable weather protection is our highest priority. Thank you for choosing Roof Replacement Inc., and please do not hesitate to reach out if you ever need anything down the road.
Posted on Google Google
Eduardo Carranza profile picture
Eduardo Carranza
27 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience. This team was professional, reliable, and easy to work with throughout the entire process.

Owner's reply
It was an absolute pleasure assisting you with your property, Eduardo! Our ultimate goal as your dedicated roofing team in Los Angeles is to provide clear, straightforward guidance from day one so you can make confident decisions about your home. Please do not hesitate to reach out if you need further roof maintenance or support down the road.
Posted on Google Google
jamie mccowen profile picture
jamie mccowen
12 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Great pricing, friendly and helpful, and the job was done well. Would recommend to anyone looking to get some remodeling done.

Owner's reply
Thank you so much for the fantastic feedback, Jamie! We're thrilled everything went smoothly with your remodeling project, and we're always here for any future roofing or home improvement needs!
Posted on Google Google
Colin McCowen profile picture
Colin McCowen
11 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Called for an estimate because I’m planning to do some remodeling, they were very nice and helpful, pricing was reasonable, and would highly recommend.

Owner's reply
Thank you for your review, Colin! It is fantastic to hear that our team could provide the clarity and support you needed for your upcoming project. Please keep us in mind whenever you are ready to take the next step!
Posted on Google Google
angel m profile picture
angel m
5 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Had them come to my house for an estimate. Not only was the price reasonable but they were super friendly and willing to work with me. I would recommend this company to anybody who’s looking to get their roof done.

Owner's reply
It was a pleasure walking you through your roofing options, Angel! Our team is dedicated to providing honest, transparent guidance so you can make the best decision for your home. Whenever you are ready to move forward with a Roof Replacement Inc, we will be right here to help.
Posted on Google Google
Jimmy Alastair Martinez Real Estate Inc. profile picture
Jimmy Alastair Martinez Real Estate Inc.
5 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Adolfo is an excellent roofer and always does a great job for my clients! I highly recommend Adolfo for all of your roofing needs.

Owner's reply
We deeply appreciate your continued partnership and recommendation, Jimmy! Ensuring your clients receive dependable inspections and seamless roofing solutions is a responsibility we take seriously. Our team are always ready to support your next project!